← Field Guide

Shelter Vs. Tent Decision System

Core Philosophy

  • Tent is the default
  • Shelters are a safety tool, not a comfort choice
  • Poor sleep and mouse exposure are accepted costs only when risk outweighs discomfort
  • Decisions are made using objective triggers, not mood or convenience

When Shelter Becomes the Right Decision

Go to a shelter if ANY ONE of the following is true:

1. Wind + Cold Combination

  • Temps below ~25°F
  • Sustained wind 15+ mph or gusts 20+ mph
  • Exposed ridge or saddle
  • You feel cold before stopping

2. Freezing Rain or Heavy Wet Snow

Automatic shelter night. No debate.

3. Ground Conditions You Cannot Mitigate

  • Solid ice
  • Snow too deep to anchor
  • No flat or drained tent sites

4. You Are Wet and Can’t Get Dry Before Dark

  • Damp clothing
  • Temps dropping
  • No sun left
  • Hands losing dexterity

5. Mental or Physical Exhaustion

  • Foggy thinking
  • Irritation during setup
  • Skipping food or water steps

Shelter reduces complexity when judgment is compromised.

What Is NOT a Shelter Trigger

  • It’s cold but dry and calm
  • You’re tired but functional
  • Others are staying there
  • You want convenience

Tent handles those conditions fine.

Winter Decision Framework - Comprehensive

Georgia vs NC Terrain Comparison (Reality)

Blood Mountain (Georgia)

  • Shorter but steeper
  • Elevation gain is compressed
  • Switchbacks exist but are aggressive
  • Descent into Neel Gap is harder than the climb
  • Punishes pacing mistakes early

Snowbird / Walnut / Max Patch (NC)

  • Longer, sustained climbs
  • Easier to find rhythm
  • Weather exposure lasts longer
  • More endurance-based suffering

Bottom line: Blood Mountain is not taller, but it hits harder sooner. You already handled equal or harder terrain in NC.

Winter Tent-Site Scoring Checklist

Score each category 0-2. Total possible: 10 points.

Interpretation:

  • 7-10 → Tent is correct
  • 4-6 → Tent only if weather is stable
  • 0-3 → Shelter is the smart move

1. Wind Protection

  • 2: Fully protected, calm
  • 1: Partial protection
  • 0: Exposed, funneling wind

2. Ground Quality

  • 2: Flat, drains well, stakes hold
  • 1: Minor slope or frozen top layer
  • 0: Ice, pooled water, unusable ground

3. Moisture Risk

  • 2: Dry ground, stable weather
  • 1: Damp but manageable
  • 0: Freezing rain or heavy wet snow

4. Setup Control

  • 2: Calm, deliberate setup
  • 1: Minor fumbling
  • 0: Hands failing, rushing, irritation

5. Overnight Confidence

Ask: “Will this still work if conditions worsen at 3 a.m.?”

  • 2: Yes, confidently
  • 1: Maybe, thin margin
  • 0: No, hoping it holds

Hope is not a winter strategy.

One-Minute Decision Prompt

Before committing to camp, ask:

  1. Am I dry right now?
  2. Is wind increasing or decreasing?
  3. Can I pitch cleanly without rushing?
  4. Will this setup keep me warm at 3 a.m.?

If any answer feels shaky, shelter is the correct call.

Shelter Night Protocol (When You Go In)

Once shelter is chosen, you switch modes.

Arrival

  • Scan for mice
  • Choose sleeping spot away from walls and corners
  • Identify food hang or bear box immediately

Food & Scent Lockdown (FIRST ACTION)

  • Food, trash, toothpaste, lip balm, sanitizer, wrappers — all together
  • Hang or box immediately
  • Nothing scented touches the floor
  • Pack stays closed

Gear Control

Keep with you:

  • Headlamp
  • Phone
  • Filter (inside bag)
  • Battery bank
  • Water bottle

Never leave loose:

  • Gloves
  • Socks
  • Trek pole handles
  • Hip belt pockets

Night Behavior

  • No food after final hang
  • No wrappers opened
  • Ignore mice unless contacting gear
  • Shoes upright, not flat

Morning Exit

  1. Pack sleep system
  2. Pack all non-food gear
  3. Retrieve food last
  4. Eat outside if possible
  5. Visual sweep for crumbs